[balletlover]

For the longest time I thought Ready or Not, but I just reread All-American Girl and decided I liked that better.

:badgrin: katie :badgrin:

[mod edit - spoiler alert]

[lrd105]

Yeah, i know. It seems that Sam is trying to grow up too quickly in the second one. She is still only a teenager and all. But, even David (as the presidents son) is acting like an adult in public, but when he is around with just Sam he is totally acting like a teenager with raging hormornes. But Sam, is just like freaking out over everything.

I still like both of the books, I just prefer the first...
LRD105

[writerserenyty]

I love them both, but to me the original is almost always better than the sequel, unless the sequel is, in some way, extraordinary.

So, I like AAG better.

[iotaa]

i prefer AAG.
i love the paint lessons. :eusa_clap:
the way sam drew an egg without using white.
and sam life in AAG was harder than RoN
so the story is more complicated

[Iluvmusic_h]

AAG for sure!!! I didn't really like RON.

~~ Mango

[jessinia]

I liked AAg better. 'Nuff said.

Jess the Shocker :o

[Iluvmusic_h]

^^ Hey we were born on the same day, just different years.

Anyway AAG was light and funny but RON was sort of, i don't know. Not as exciting. My sister read both books and she also like RON better.

~~ Mango

[Iluvmusic_h]

^ I meant AAG.

[AWishOnAStar]

i think i like AAG better because Sam seemed more like me i guess. I think she changed a little in RON. because in RON its all about her talking about being ready to do it with david. AAG just seemed better to me.

Gwen :m:

[Alone and Forgotten]

I liked All American Girl better. I found Ready Or Not a bit repetitive.

[PinkMascara]

I really liked AAG, but I wasn't very keen on RON, so it would have to me the original for me.

[jessy_me_lovetoread]

I like All American Girl better because it has a more entertaining vibe to it.

[lmnt]

AAg hands down. I enjoyed RoN but liked AAG better.

-Gina :D :D

[Hugs*&*Kisses]

I liked RoN more than AAG.

Can't think why...I'll come back to this later.

Joanne_x

[sweet_Myra]

I liked AAG better than RON. I haven't exactly read RON but I read the summary and I didn't find it as intresting as AAG. Besides, I totally loved the ending of the first book, that I am kinda afraid that reading the second book will ruin the ending for me. It was really beatiful and just.....perfect.


~Maryam~

[balletlover]

Quote

I liked AAG better than RON. I haven't exactly read RON but I read the summary and I didn't find it as intresting as AAG. Besides, I totally loved the ending of the first book, that I am kinda afraid that reading the second book will ruin the ending for me. It was really beatiful and just.....perfect.

You probably should read RoN. I don't think the ending ruins the ending of AAG, but it depends how you feel about it, I guess.

[weasel1231]

I prefer Ready or Not. Come on itz a bit of fun :D

[AdventureSeeker]

I prefered AAG. I was laughing my head off most of the time. It is such a creative and original novel/story! :D

Quote

Anyway AAG was light and funny

That's what I liked about it.

Taz

[targetluver76]

i thought ready or not talked too much about sex...

<3 ~shannon =D

[sassysweetstart]

when i first read RON i liked AAG better. though i have to admit part of it was because the cover of RON was a bit disturbing to me (it took me awhile to get use to it) so i didn't like it. but when i reread it some more i found that i did like it. in my opinion i think it compared with AAG but in different ways. both books are different and deal with different stuff. for me, i can't really compare either of them.

[**CaliAngelKate**]

I perfer Ready or Not. Don't have a good explaination for it. I just do. :)

But I still totally love All American Girl.

[~Pseudonym~]

I love both books! I loved reading about how Sam and David became an item in AAG. While RON...it's good too. I really loved reading those parts with Lucy and her nerd...LOL, I forgot his name. They were both sooooo sweet. Justl ike Sam and David.

Although when it's just about Sam and David, I (along with a lot of you, probably) think AAG is better.

^_^

[pupcrazy]

AAG it's more interesting RON is a little complicated and in the first book it actually talks about lots of different stuff unlike the second one that mostly only talks about sex

[sassysweetstart]

Quote

I perfer Ready or Not. Don't have a good explaination for it. I just do.

lol. i do, i think part of the major reason i like it might have something to do with a certian faucet. lol.

kat

[~*~*HeyHoTheCherryO~*~*]

AAG all the way!

[nickyb789]

ya AAG was like so interesting

but RON was like those really awkward movie sequels

it almost wasn't needed

[liverbird]

Ermm I Think RoN But Its Been Ages Since I'v Read AAG So Maybe When i Get Round To Reading It Again Ill Change My Mind =]
XxXxX

[violagirl]

I liked All American Girl better. RoN was good but got reptitive after awhile.

[Divalectable217]

All American Girl! For sure dudes! :mgbubblegum: Smiz better! :m:

Man this is such a drag. :user:

[dev]

Ready or not!! I enjoyed it soo much more. I like All American Girl, but Ready or not was just so amazing!!!! Awqward but funny... They were both good, but they were so differnt.

[OMGitsKG]

I really like both books, but all American Girl is my favorite. :] It was more of my kind of story.
I loved Ready or Not, too, and I was thrilled that there was a sequel to AAG. Just...the first ones are always better for me, unless it's a series like Harry Potter or something.

♥ Katie

[sweetsapphire83]

I really liked both AAG and RON, but between the two, I'd say AAG is my favorite.

[sese_luvs_pd]

i would have to say AAG because i didnt even know it had a sequel after, it was perfect the way it was but when RON came out i was like is there another one, it kind of leaves u hanging

[CutiePie27]

AGG is way better. I liked the ending in RoN but you can't beat the original. Besides, more stuff seems to happen in AGG, the whole of RoN is pretty much just her worrying about her first time.

[Michael lover22]

AGG is WAY WAY WAY WAY better!!!!!!
RoN was just dumb I think it's probably Megs worst book.

I mean GIVE ME A BREAK.

I hated it.

Love:MG

[Michael lover22]

Also I would like to add they talk about sex way to much.
It doesn't make me un-comfortable or anything I just got tired of it.

Love:MG

[Shaheen]

I've already read AAG and I didn't like it so much.I found it a bit boring, so I didn't read RoN.I just wanted to know if i did the right thing.

[mycatzrdabomb]

I liked RoN better, but that's probably cause it has... well you know. I can't help I have a warped little mind. Blame my friends, they did it to me. lol :D

Sara