[Shanitaurus13]

If they ever made All American Girl into a movie, this is who I think would play Sam's character perfect;



Miley Cyrus. What do you think?





( I hope this works!)

[BFlove]

I'm a huge fan of Miley, but I don't know if she's right for this role. She is a little bit too young right now, but maybe if they make the movie in a few years...

[becca_280]

Miley's definitely not someone I could imagine as Sam...but then I don't really know who I could imagine as her...

[balletlover]

^I agree with you. Miley is too young (isn't she only 13?) and just doesn't seem like Sam.

[Ari-san]

There's no way she looks 13 years old. I think she's 15.

[Ari-san]

^ Ooops! It was meant to read "There's no way she is 13 years old". I just think she looks more mature than a 13 year old.

[not4got10]

She's either 13 or 14. She's about my sister's age and my sister is 13.

[balletlover]

I could have sworn somewhere it was said she was thirteen...but with my genius memory, it might have been something I read 2 years ago.

[Lannfo75]

I think Miley Cyrus just turned 14 a couple of months ago. I'm not sure if she'll make a good Sam in a movie, but I guess she's an option.

[Ari-san]

She's 14, turning 15 this year, as she was born on the 23rd November, 1992.

[BubblesInMyDietCoke]

I have a best friend named Sam, who is EXACTLY like the Sam in this book.
Now THAT is weird.

[Amneris]

I always imagine Amy Davidson as Sam...

Amy Davidson was the middle child in 8 Simples rules to date my teenage daughter (the one with John Ritter)


:icon_flower:

[the_tall_girl]

Miley's not her real name.

Straight from Wikipedia:

Quote

She was named Destiny Hope because her parents thought that she would accomplish great things. Cyrus gained her nickname "Miley" because she kept smiling ("Smiley") as a youngster.

http://en.wikipedia....iki/Miley_Cyrus

Just thought I'd share that with you.

Gah! I really have to go now.

[Hugs*&*Kisses]

She probably would be too old, but I think Anneliese van der Pol would make a good Sam... but she's 22 so I wouldn't of though it would be possible, however, Anne Hathaway was the same age when they made the second Princess Diares film .. so you never know ... ??

http://photos.lacocc...11/02/91102.jpg

In "That's so Raven" she plays Chelsea...

[the_tall_girl]

Miley Cirus?! No way! She looks nothing like Sam, nor has the same personality for that matter.

I'll think of someone. And when I do, it'll be good!

*dramatic exit*

[megisthebest]

Amneris, on Jan 21 2007, 11:40 AM, said:

I always imagine Amy Davidson as Sam...

Amy Davidson was the middle child in 8 Simples rules to date my teenage daughter (the one with John Ritter)
:icon_flower:

Oh my gosh, I totally agree with you. That's who I've always pictured playing Sam. She looks almost exactly like Sam, maybe except that she's just a little too old. Oh well.

[MiZunderStuD]

I thought Amy Davidson as well. I think she would suit the role perfect.
http://www.the8rules.co.uk/Gallery/albums/userpics/10002/normal_pdavidson.jpg

or Stacey Farber
http://www.yorku.ca/ylife/2006/07-July/07-03/images/stacey_farber-clip.jpg



___Aqeelah

[LightningStrikes]

:icon_eek: No, no, no Miley Cyrus please!!! XP




I think Stacey Farber (as someone else said) would make a great Sam!!! ^^




...And still a mega no to Miley...>>;

[david+sam]

how about in All American Girl Hilary Duff with Red Hair and in Ready Or Not Hilary Duff with black hair??
I think it will work! besides miley would go better as lucy with the hanna montana wig!

http://www.thehollyw...uff_400x300.jpg

[megisthebest]

david+sam, on Jul 6 2007, 12:33 private message, said:

how about in All American Girl Hilary Duff with Red Hair and in Ready Or Not Hilary Duff with black hair??
I think it will work! besides miley would go better as lucy with the hanna montana wig!

http://www.thehollyw...uff_400x300.jpg

you've got a good point, but miley looks too young to be hilary's older sister. i think, if miley were to be in the movie at all, hilary should play lucy and miley play sam. i don't picture miley being a good sam though...

[Sam*the*BookWorm*]

I :heartbeat: Miley Cyrus, but she wouldn't be right for the role; even if she was older. I think Miley is really different from Sam. Plus she's portrayed as more of a country girl then a city girl, do you see what I mean? Amy Davidson would be good to play her. And maybe, just maybe, a young Lindsay Lohan when she was still a red head and wasn't into drugs and stuff. Another girl that would be good to play Sam would be Charlotte Arnold (she plays on a Naturally, Sadie).

http://content.answers.com/main/content/wp/en/thumb/f/f6/220px-CharlotteArnold.jpg
Charlotte Arnold

[megisthebest]

I totally agree with you. Charlotte would make a good Sam, although I can't really picture her looking as dark as Sam does.

[Sam*the*BookWorm*]

If shes a good actress, which I think she is, she should be able to.

*Sam*

[tink1202]

I Also Am A Fan Of Miley Cyrus. But I Don't Think She Has The Right Image. I Mean How Do You See A Teen Pop Star Like Miley Being A Girl Who Dies Her Hair Black, Isn't Popular And Has Sex?[/size]

[tink1202]

BubblesInMyDietCoke, on Jan 20 2007, 01:26 private message, said:

I have a best friend named Sam, who is EXACTLY like the Sam in this book.
Now THAT is weird.

When You Say Just Like Sam Do You Mean Has The Best Boyfriend Ever Like Sam?

[little rascal]

Personally my opinion on Miley Cyrus will not be what you like but I really and I mean really don't like her and personally she doesn't have the right personality or voice (twang) for Sam so please I think we should go with someone not so country. I like Amy Davidson that would be good...

Ashley

[~mytruequerida~]

megisthebest, on Jul 6 2007, 10:29 private message, said:

you've got a good point, but miley looks too young to be hilary's older sister. i think, if miley were to be in the movie at all, hilary should play lucy and miley play sam. i don't picture miley being a good sam though...

I agree with you. I just don't see miley as a 'Sam'. I think Amy Davidson or Stacy Farber would be a good Sam, and maybe hilary with blonde hair to be Lucy

[jessinia]

Quote

^I agree with you. Miley is too young (isn't she only 13?) and just doesn't seem like Sam.

Miley's 15.

Jess the Shocker :blink:

[Jellybean_lover]

MiZunderStuD, on Apr 2 2007, 07:27 PM, said:

I thought Amy Davidson as well. I think she would suit the role perfect.
http://www.the8rules.co.uk/Gallery/albums/userpics/10002/normal_pdavidson.jpg

or Stacey Farber
http://www.yorku.ca/ylife/2006/07-July/07-03/images/stacey_farber-clip.jpg
___Aqeelah

I have red hair maybe i could do the part.lol just jokin but i really do think Amy Davidson would be perfect for this movie

[Lenetta]

[quote name='Lenetta' date='Sep 17 2007, 04:41 PM' post='1951366']
I don't know about you guys, but this: http://www.celebopedia.com/renee-olstead/images/renee-olstead.jpg (Renee Olstead) is what I pictured Samantha Madison would look like. Not exactly, but she fits my image.

This is a better closeup of her

She would make a great Lucy http://www.tvguide.com/images/pgimg/kaley-cuoco1.jpg

And as for David, I guess Liam Aiken would be a good choice...

Jack I think would be best played by http://cdn.channel.aol.com/getty/E/2005-03-01/52249110FB048_the_E.jpg
and Trent Ford

Trent Ford

[*mwahaha*]

I'm here to revive the thread!

Hugs*&*Kisses, on Jan 21 2007, 01:51 PM, said:

She probably would be too old, but I think Anneliese van der Pol would make a good Sam... but she's 22 so I wouldn't of though it would be possible, however, Anne Hathaway was the same age when they made the second Princess Diares film .. so you never know ... ??

http://photos.lacocc...11/02/91102.jpg

In "That's so Raven" she plays Chelsea...

But I can sort of see her. In a way, she would fit it, but in another way, I just keep thinking back to the unusual Chelsea that she used to act as. I can kind of also see Emma Taylor-Isherwood (Strange Days of Blake Holsey High), except with red hair.

[CharliePantsxxx]

Eeeew, not Anneliese Van Der Pol as Sam!

Miley would be better, but she'd be a rubbish Sam too... hmmm....

I can't think of anyone! :(

Char :m:

[Shot in Sarajevo]

Oh dear, Catherine Tate keeps popping into my head. (It's the red hair, I swear.)

Ah, now I'm seeing Bonnie Wright. If only she weren't British.

[MissBeeJones]

Oh good grief, if ever they do make an All American Girl movie (I'm totally wishing it too), NO Miley. She'd make an awful Sam.

[venushalley]

MissBeeJones, on Aug 4 2008, 11:26 PM, said:

Oh good grief, if ever they do make an All American Girl movie (I'm totally wishing it too), NO Miley. She'd make an awful Sam.

I agree. It needs to be somebody with a quirky edge. Miley is too mainstream.